Extra Inning Games (since 2000)
| DATE | OPPONENT | INNINGS | RESULT | SCORE | GAME-WINNING PLAY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4/11/2026 | Calvin | 11 | L | 5-3 | |
| 3/28/2026 | Hope | 12 | W | 8-6 | 2-run single by EJ Suggitt |
| 5/5/2024 | Trine (Ind.) | 12 | W | 4-0 | 3-run homer by Gabriel Kirck |
| 4/17/2021 | Trine (Ind.) | 8 | W | 5-4 | RBI-single by Logan Sella |
| 3/9/2021 | Saint Xavier (Ill.) | 8 | W | 3-2 | RBI-double by Ben Compton |
| 5/5/2019 | Kalamazoo | 8 | W | 6-4 | wild pitch |
| 4/27/2019 | Calvin | 11 | W | 3-2 | RBI-single by Seamus Mitchell |
| 3/23/2019 | Albion | 10 | L | 2-1 | |
| 4/22/2018 | Alma | 10 | W | 7-6 | error by pitcher |
| 4/8/2018 | Adrian | 10 | L | 10-9 | |
| 2/25/2018 | Wis.-Platteville | 10 | W | 7-6 | RBI-single by Logan Sella |
| 3/16/2017 | Plattsburgh State (N.Y.) | 13 | L | 10-7 | |
| 4/30/2016 | Calvin | 8 | L | 7-4 | |
| 4/12/2016 | Albion | 11 | W | 7-6 | RBI-single by Austin Cleaver |
| 4/11/2015 | Trine (Ind.) | 9 | L | 3-1 | |
| 3/15/2013 | Rockford (Ill.) | 11 | W | 13-6 | RBI-double by Peter Panos |
| 3/9/2013 | Hiram (Ohio) | 14 | W | 7-6 | SF by Drew Thompson |
| 4/11/2012 | Aquinas | 10 | L | 6-5 | |
| 3/25/2012 | Alma | 8 | L | 3-2 | |
| 5/6/2011 | Trine (Ind.) | 8 | L | 6-5 | |
| 5/6/2011 | Trine (Ind.) | 8 | W | 3-2 | |
| 4/14/2011 | Albion | 10 | W | 1-0 | SF by Joel Peters |
| 3/31/2011 | Kalamazoo | 8 | L | 4-3 | |
| 5/4/2010 | Oakland | 8 | L | 5-4 | |
| 4/29/2010 | Alma | 8 | W | 6-5 | HR by Ben Kosmalski |
| 3/23/2010 | Rochester | 8 | L | 9-7 | |
| 3/7/2010 | Elms (Mass.) | 12 | L | 13-12 | |
| 5/1/2009 | Calvin | 8 | L | 8-6 | |
| 4/25/2009 | Albion | 9 | L | 6-5 | |
| 3/23/2009 | Rochester | 14 | W | 14-13 | RBI-single by Phil Sullens |
| 3/9/2009 | St. John Fisher (N.Y.) | 10 | W | 10-9 | RBI-single by Brandon Goodman |
| 3/8/2009 | Pitt-Greensburg (Pa.) | 8 | L | 17-14 | |
| 5/6/2008 | Hope | 10 | L | 5-4 | |
| 4/19/2008 | Albion | 11 | W | 3-2 | RBI-single by Ryan Hodges |
| 4/3/2008 | Kalamazoo | 10 | W | 5-4 | SF by Eric Quinn |
| 3/7/2008 | St. Joseph's (Maine) | 10 | L | 17-14 | |
| 4/21/2007 | Calvin | 8 | L | 10-3 | |
| 4/13/2007 | Alma | 12 | L | 2-1 | |
| 3/31/2007 | Albion | 12 | L | 13-10 | |
| 3/29/2007 | Albion | 8 | L | 8-7 | |
| 3/8/2007 | Wesley (Del.) | 12 | L | 4-3 | |
| 4/29/2006 | Tri-State (Ind.) | 11 | W | 6-4 | RBI-single by Jon Van Son |
| 3/30/2006 | Albion | 8 | L | 7-4 | |
| 4/16/2005 | Calvin | 8 | L | 3-2 | |
| 3/20/2005 | Wabash (Ind.) | 11 | W | 7-6 | RBI-single by Nick McIntosh |
| 4/1/2004 | Rochester | 8 | L | 5-2 | |
| 3/21/2004 | Wabash (Ind.) | 8 | W | 4-3 | SF by Beau Locker |
| 3/2/2004 | Concordia (Ill.) | 8 | L | 9-8 | |
| 4/13/2003 | Rochester | 8 | W | 4-3 | RBI-single by Beau Locker |
| 4/12/2003 | Alma | 8 | W | 4-3 | RBI-single by James Virden |
| 3/5/2003 | Thiel (Pa.) | 9 | L | 11-14 | |
| 5/11/2002 | Alma | 8 | L | 7-6 | |
| 4/23/2002 | Defiance (Ohio) | 10 | L | 6-5 | |
| 4/19/2002 | Albion | 10 | W | 9-8 | error by SS |
| 4/14/2001 | Orchard Lake St. Mary's | 8 | L | 3-2 |